A new tax credit for producers and producers’ suppliers has sparked a debate about whether producers should be paid more than they actually earn for their products.
The debate erupted on Monday after a tax-reform bill that aims to raise $1 trillion over the next 10 years passed the Senate with only Republican support.
If passed, the bill would provide a $10,000 tax credit to producers of the most profitable products.
The credit would be doubled if the producer produces at least $1.4 million in revenue.
The legislation would apply to any producer of goods with gross income over $1 million, excluding the small business tax credit, which is capped at $500,000 for manufacturers.
There is no requirement for producers to pay a percentage of their sales to the credit.
Producers will get a credit worth $500 per product, plus the $10 credit, per barrel of oil that they produce, whichever is greater.
In addition, the credit is subject to inflation, which will be indexed to the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and other data.
When it comes time to pay the credit, producers will be required to pay $1 for every barrel of petroleum they produce.
At the same time, they will be eligible for a $5,000 deduction from their income tax for any amount paid to the IRS by producers, which includes the $1 credit.
The tax credit has sparked fierce debate over the value of producers’ income.
A study released last month by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP) estimated that producers receive an average of $2,500 per barrel per year in the form of a credit for the tax credit.
The study also found that producers would only be eligible to claim $7,000 in the tax credits and that consumers would only receive $3,500.
Consumers, however, will only receive a $1 refund on the $5 credit.
If consumers choose not to take the credit they would still owe $10.
This debate was exacerbated by a tax cut in the House that will give an additional $4 billion to the Treasury over the coming decade, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center (TPC).
But the CBPP report also noted that the increase in credit amounts is offset by the increase of excise taxes on fuel, machinery and equipment used to produce oil, resulting in a $2.4 trillion deficit reduction over the decade.
Critics have called the credit a windfall for producers.
“The producers credit is a winddown of the tax cuts for the middle class, which has been the main driver of the economic recovery, and the producers credit has no real revenue upside for the federal government,” wrote Josh Earnest, a spokesman for the White House Budget Office, in a statement on Monday.
It’s unclear how the tax breaks will be funded.
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) last month estimated that the credit would only generate $5 billion in revenue over the 10-year period, and that the average tax reduction for the wealthy would be $5.5 million.
However, the CBO noted that this would be offset by $1,700 in tax increases on those making over $100,000 per year.
The CBO added that this increase would be paid for by the average middle-class family, who would receive an additional tax cut of $1 a year.
Although the tax increase on the wealthiest individuals is likely to be significant, the Tax Policy Network (TPM) estimated last month that the overall tax cuts will cost the government $2 trillion over 10 years.
According to TPM, this is because the tax increases will be paid by the wealthiest households, which would receive a significant tax cut, while everyone else would see their tax rates increase.
To offset the impact of the credit for consumers, the CBO also calculated that it would cost the federal Treasury $1 billion over the period from 2025 to 2035.
The total amount the Treasury would have to pay in the interest would be more than $5 trillion.
While the Senate passed the bill, President Donald Trump has said he will sign the bill into law.
On Monday, a White House official told CNBC the president would sign the legislation, and said he expects it to pass the House.
As for the bill’s potential impact on the budget, the Congressional Budget OMB has said it would “modestly” affect the budget balance in 2021.
With the tax changes being passed into law, the Senate and House are now expected to reconcile the bill in the coming days.
Follow Joe on Twitter: @joe_brunt and Sarah on Twitter.